Session 1
Talk show Host: Ladies and gentlemen! Good evening! Here
begins our session today. As you know, our aim is to bring clarity to seemingly
complex personal problems, through the medium of psychodrama. Certainly
something with audience appeal... We are competing with talk shows, as well as
those so-called reality shows. But only we are original! Only us! Judge for
yourselves! (looks
around the audience) Ah! Doctor Manz, there you are! (addresses the audience again) Dr Manz has
informed me that he has a problem on his hands. He is hoping to solve it with
our help. Please, Doctor, come up here and take a seat. (gestures to Frank to come up on stage and sit
down on the chair next to him) The stage is our most effective tool. And
honesty! Absolute honesty. Never deceive oneself! It’s very hard, of course, but we must try! (to Frank) Please,
take a seat! (Frank sits down) So, young man. What is it that’s torturing you?
Frank: My marriage!
Host: Marriage, that
outdated social institution!
Frank: Yeah, well, there probably is something that’s
not right about it anymore. I mean, not just my marriage, but this whole
construct of a man and woman living together. What’s the point?
Host: Let’s hear it!
Frank: Hear what?
Host: Your story!
Frank: Well it’s quite
a normal story! Happens everywhere, all the time. In
fact, it’s boring!
Host: Just be honest,
Frank!
Frank: Alright, Anna
and I, we were happily married. If you can call it that.We had worked towards a
goal and, somehow, everything worked out. Work. Love, well, sex. Yeah, honestly.
But then, whilst I whilst doing my research work in Leipzig I met a student,
who I fell in love with. It just happened. I’ve never been free of her since.
Now she has her degree and wants to come to Berlin. Would
should I do?
Host: Does your wife
know about this student?
Frank: She understands.
I think.
Host: Is she here?
Frank: Yes. (points out his
wife in the first row)
Host: Hello, Mrs Manz!
It’s nice of you to have come. (to Frank) You said your wife understands. I might even
imagine, from what I know, that she wants to help you. Am I right, Mrs Manz?
Anna: (hesitating) Yes,
that’s right.
Host: Then I suggest
we get to the point. And we’ll do that by having you both show us a scene from
your life. Ok? Preferably, you’ll take a scene in which your problems were last
brought up. Please, Mrs Manz, come up on the stage with us. (to the audience) Often
in life, people say one thing and do the opposite. (Anna comes onto the stage) Please, take a seat. (Anna sits down) These two people (enters the audience) are not hiding
from their problems. That’s very clear. Nowadays, excuse my frankness, married
couples head for swingers clubs and think that they can cement their marriages
by doing so. They gratify their lust like animals, licking each other’s pussies
and cocks before some hardcore screwing. Poor creatures! There you have it! (to Anna and Frank)
Try to reconstruct the scene. Ideally, you will be talking to each other as
usual, but using…asides, saying aloud what you would normally only be thinking. Do you understand? Thoughts
that would otherwise be kept secret. That way, it will be easier for us
to understand your motives. Have a think and then off you go! (moves into the
background)
Frank: (to Anna) Yeah, maybe, hmm, the scene
the other day, before I left?
Anna: Yeah, ok.
Frank: (after a short pause) What
are you thinking about?
Anna: Do you know what
day it is today?
Frank: Of course! Our anniversary.
Anna: The eleventh!
Frank: Shit!
Anna: Oh, great!
Frank: (to the Host) I can’t do it! I’m not an
actor.
Host: Please! Quiet
now! (to the
audience) You must understand – the pair are
naturally nervous in front of so many people. Excuse the comparison but getting
naked in a swingers club and letting a totally unknown woman play with your
penis, whilst she’s entered from behind, is now less of a big deal than baring
your soul in public. (to
Frank again) So, young man. This is what you
wanted! Finally, a step in the right direction.
Frank: I never thought this would happen. (almost reproachfully to Anna) Aren’t you
bothered about talking about the whole fiasco?
Anna: Not anymore.
Frank: What did we do
wrong? What did I do wrong?
Anna: Where is this
hate coming from?
Frank: Hate?!
Anna: Why can’t we
come to an understanding?
Frank: It’s probably my
fault.
Anna: I agree. That’s
why you can make decisions more easily than me. You’re level-headed and
independent. I always need the assurance of another person somehow, even when I
have a specific goal in mind.
Frank: That’s not how
it is at all. Before we came to Berlin, you were the independent one, not me.
Anna: No! I was just
trying not to be dependent. But it’s got harder and harder recently. It was
absolute hell for me, being at home when you weren’t there, when you didn’t show
up as planned. How often I sat and waited! Absolute hell!
Frank: Well then you
hid it well.
Anna: It was all just
a form of defence!
Frank: You know I care
about you.
Anna: Then why aren’t
you taking me with you this weekend?
Frank: She wouldn’t
open up or probably say a single word.
Anna: And? Would that
be our problem?
Frank: I care about her
too. I can’t give either of you up.
Anna: And if we had a
child?
Frank: Don’t start all
that! I’m glad we don’t have any. It would just make everything more
complicated. God, I’m clearly the selfish one...
Anna: Does she think
you’re selfish too?
Frank: I would have
thought so.
Anna: And why does she
think that?
Frank: Because I don’t
pay her attention anymore.
Anna: I don’t get it.
You’re always hanging round hers when you’re in Leipzig.
Frank: Don’t
exaggerate! Maybe recently, yeah. But actually,
everything was purely platonic. Childish in fact. She
had hoped that I‘d say something. But I was a coward, avoided it. When she
found out that I was leaving Leipzig, she couldn’t hold herself back any
longer.
Anna: And how long was
it ‘platonic’ like that for?
Frank: My interest, a
timid interest, began about...a year and a half ago.
Anna: A year and a
half!
Frank: I don’t know how
it was possible but my feelings for her just became more and more intense. It
just completely came over me. I didn’t know what I was doing. And, at the same
time, my feelings for you changed. It just happened like that! God know how
that happens! They didn’t go cold exactly, no, but something changed. Fucking
shit!
Anna: We’ve been
through so much together. I had hoped that, if something like this happened, it
wouldn’t tear us apart.
Frank: I didn’t want it
to, really I didn’t but, deep down, it sounds strange to say it, I mean maybe
unknowingly, yeah unknowingly, I was secretly asking myself over and over again
whether it makes sense living together.
Anna: And I was
worried about you.
Frank: Well, we’ll see
from these three days.
Anna: I can’t bear to
imagine it. My husband with another woman, quite casually in a hotel, and me...
Host: Thank you! So
let’s see up to here. You’ve been married for eleven years and don’t have any
children. What does that mean? Love doesn’t demand marriage. Or what are your
thoughts on that? Is the purpose of getting married not to have children? The
underlying reason for the fact that you don’t have any is clearly deeply
complicated. Presumably that same lack of decision-making
power. (to
the audience) It is always astounding, ladies and gentlemen, how little
people are aware of the fact that, every day, they must make decisions. And, of
these decisions, the one whether to have tea or coffee at breakfast, remains
the most harmless. And so to you: a chid may be the cause of a new crisis but
the other possibility is that it will make a marriage stronger. Did you want a
child, Anna?
Anna: Not in the
beginning but...lately, yeah.
Host: In the hope that
a baby could help you to keep Frank?
Anna: Yeah, well,
partly.
Host: Perhaps there’s
a relatiobship between Frank’s homelife before he was married and his reluctance
to have a baby. (to
Frank) What’s your story?
Frank: God, what am I
meant to say to that?
Host: Do you have any
brothers or sisters?
Frank: Three sisters.
Host: Three?
Frank: Yes.
Host: How old?
Frank: All younger.
Host: What’s your
relationship like with them?
Frank: Not particularly
good.
Host: In what way?
Frank: I think I‘ve got
more serious goals in life than they have.
Host: Are you much
older?
Frank: There’s three
years between me and the eldest.
Host: Are your sisters
affectionate towards you?
Frank: If they are then
they express it in a negative way, through criticism.
Host: And what’s it
like with your mother and father?
Frank: Good. You know. Although...it’s different with each of them.
Host: Did you get
married with your parents’ blessing?
Frank: They didn’t want
us to.
Host: Oh! And why not?
Frank: They didn’t
think it was financially viable for us to get married. At
that time anyway.
Host: And? Have
financial difficulties contributed to your current situation?
Frank: No. No, that has
nothing to do with it.
Host: Right, ok.
That’s not of much help to us now. On to Ellen. How
did this affair come about?
Frank: I met Ellen in
September, at the beginning of the academic year. She caught my eye because she
always sat in the front row. She then sat there in my seminars for two years,
always very shy and retiring. I felt drawn towards her. She had a way of moving
and of looking at me, it was always like being struck by lightning. And yet I
always looked on her as a child. Already forcing myself not
to do anything stupid.
Host: Is she much
younger than you?
Frank: Fairly.
Host: So when did your
interest no longer seem stupid?
Frank: Hard to say.
There was some sort of impetus when the relationship with my wife was not
so...so thrilling.
Host: And what was the
reason for that? Was there a sort of breaking point?
Frank: Yeah, I think
there was.
Host: And when was
that?
Frank: When we moved in
with my wife’s family.
Host: (to Anna) Would
you agree?
Anna: Well, in
hindsight, I’d say that we were already having problems.
Host: In what way?
Anna: Let’s say we
were in a tight spot. After our landlady passed away, we had to leave the room
we were subletting and where we’d obviously become very close. We moved in with
my parents, to save money as well.
Host: And suddenly you
weren’t as close anymore!
Frank: I always felt
like I was being watched.
Host: Wait a second! (to Anna) Did
your parents approve of you getting married?
Anna: My mother
objected to it because, well, she didn’t really trust Frank. And my father was
convinced it was wrong.
Host: Hardly a good
basis on which to move into their home.
Anna: We were really
too old to.
Host: How old were you
when you got married?
Anna: Twenty-six.
Host: And yourself?
Frank: Twenty-eight.
Can I say something on this subject – it was just unfortunate that we had to
move in with her family. Anna has a twin sister, who’s a real snob, borderline
neurotic even. She was always interfering. In things that
really didn’t have anything at all to do with her.
Anna: I had tried to
break away from my parents’ influence. Then suddenly we were both at their
mercy.
Host: What made it so
bad?
Anna: Should I tell it
like it is?
Frank: Her parents
lived in their own little bubble, I imagine they’d
been somehow let down by life. I was always glad when the weekend was over.
Host: How long did you
live with Anna’s parents?
Frank: Nearly two
years.
Host: Did you
contribute to the family’s living costs?
Frank: My wife helped
with the housework.
Host: Ok. So it was
quite a good set-up then. From an economic perspective.
Frank: It was
appealing, yes.
Host: You thought
you’d married one person but instead you were all of a sudden married to a
whole family.
Anna: At some point, I
realised there was conflict but I could never have guessed that it went so
deep. My two brothers and twin sister were always there. They were without
spouses or real friends and all somehow resented the fact that one of their
sisters could be so independent and want her own life.
There was constant friction.
Host: (to Frank) What
was your relationship like with her twin sister?
Frank: That I do know:
complicated. She liked Anna to a certain extent and yet she still rejected her.
She seemed to want to build up a sort of, I don’t know, friendly affection towards
me. She was always coming to me with some problem or other, as if little things
were really important. So she would act as if, sometimes, if I’d wanted to, I
don’t know... Sometimes I was deliberately off with her. Also, it was
impossible for her to establish a stable relationship with men. She had a habit
of starting something, casting her net, she was quite subtle about it, but
sooner or later, either she or the man would always break the relationship off.
That’s when she’d be all keen on me.
Host: Thank you! That’ll
do for now. Or was there ever something between you and the sister?
Frank: No way, she
wasn‘t my type at all.
Host: Thank you. (to the audience) It must be said that it is rare to get
such an honest account as the one Frank has just given us. Let us now try, in
just as honest a fashion, to form to an initial judgement. The impression I get
is that for both of them, for Anna as for Frank, it was impossible to put an
end the scene just now, although they were beginning to go round in circles. That
leads us to an interesting phanomenon that most likely applies to their
problem. I mean the fact that there are men and women, who are quite capable of
starting something new, but cannot then bring it to an end. For the most part,
this inability is the common thread running through their whole life. They
carry the weight on their shoulders, so to speak. Usually, this, handicap shall
we say, first comes to light when they want to leave the family home but it is
not possible for them to really break free. The parents often have to make the
decisions for them. Frank is a prime example. It seems to that me that he would
prefer it if the women decided! (to Frank) It would have suited you if Anna had said that
she didn’t want to stand in your way but to get a divorce. And it would also
have suited you if Ellen had said that she may well be in love with you but was
too young for a proper relationship and that you should go back to your wife.
In this way, she would have taken responsibility for the decision. I get the
impression that you are suffering from your indecision. You could probably
satisfy both women for long enough, that’s not normally the problem. But you cannot
resolve the conflict and so the two women suffer with you. Although,
‘suffer’ is
perhaps used too frequently. It is more that you are torn between the
misery that comes from reflecting on the reality of your actions, and the haste
with which this may be overlooked. So Frank, please act out your last meeting
with Ellen.
Frank: (perplexed) With Ellen?
Host: Yes, with Miss
Reich. I invited her. Please, Ellen, come in.
(Ellen comes in, Anna runs out.)
Host: Don’t worry,
Frank, my assistant will look after your wife. Ellen, hello there, nice of you
to come, thank you. As you could probably hear from
outside, we have already touched on some problems. Now I’d like to include you.
So here’s my question: You recently met up with Frank?
Ellen: Yes.
Host: Where?
Ellen: In a guesthouse
in Southend.
Host: Did the meeting
go smoothly or was there any trouble?
Ellen: We had a row.
Frank: Would you call
it that?
Ellen: Wouldn’t you?
Host: About what?
Ellen: On the last day.
I brought you breakfast in bed.
Host: You brought it
to him?
Ellen: Yeah, for us.
Host: And that’s why
you had an argument?
Ellen: No! A row! It
was just a row!
Host: Row, friction,
there are lots of words for it, and nothing quite fits. So please, act out this
situation. Remind yourselves and show us, as best you can, what happened. Take
a seat, imagine, this is the breakfast table. Ready to go?
Ellen: Ok.
Host: Then begin!
Frank: I’m not prepared
for this.
Host: Not a problem.
Just be spontaneous, from memory. Please!
Frank: I really don’t
know! Yeah... (he tries to remember) How did it happen again? (to Ellen) Can
you remember?
Ellen: More or less, just
act something out!
Frank: Right! Let’s
start. Did you sleep well?
Ellen: Excellent,
thanks.
Frank: Other than that?
Ellen: If you’re
asking: these three days have been the most precious we’ve had since you went
away.
Frank: I thought so
too. Having to leave was really awful. But my feelings for you didn’t change
when you weren’t there.
Ellen: How’s Anna?
Frank: Come on, leave
her out of this!
Ellen: Does she know
that we’re together?
Frank: It’s a difficult
time for her, obviously.
Ellen: Are you sure
that she can handle it?
Frank: She has to.
Ellen: It would be
easier for you if you stayed with her.
Frank: I think she’ll
get over it in time.
Ellen: It’s stupid, I
know, but I have a guilty conscience. It’s her I feel sorry for in all this. I
feel guilty.
Frank: We have so much
to talk about.
Ellen: We do indeed,
lots. We have to talk openly about this situation for once.
Frank: I don’t want to
lose you.
Ellen: I’m the intruder.
I’m dragging you away from Anna.
Frank: Have I ever told
you I love you?
Ellen: The problem is, I started it.
Frank: I don’t know if
I could bear to live apart from you. Shit! (to the Host) That’s not how it was! We weren’t sitting
at the table, we were in bed! You think completely differently there.
Host: Then please!
Here is a nice wide couch. Use the furniture. Within reason when
in public. If you know what I mean.
Frank: Yes! (to Ellen) Come
on! (Ellen and Frank lie down on the
couch)
Host: Try to find the
right position. Cast your mind back and pick up the story again.
Frank: Yeah, I am. (puts his arm
around Ellen, moves in to kiss her, pauses) Hmm, it’s weird! I don’t know
whether I should say that here...
Host: But of course!
Frank: I’ve just suddenly realised something. I don’t
know.
Host: Do tell.
Frank: Ok, here’s the truth: As soon as I get close to
Ellen, I have a tremendous need for affection. It just takes over me, I don’t
know why. She exudes something that magically attracts me. It’s a lust for
love, a need for affection. Feelings that I never get with
Anna. I must be jinxed!
Host: Ok, I understand. But then there must be other
emotions. You left Ellen anyway. Please let’s get back to the point. Ellen,
perhaps you’ll be of help. How were you feeling at the time?
Frank: Think about it carefully.
Ellen: (after a moment’s hesitation) Yeah,
kind of the same. When you left Leeds, I felt like it was all over. I never
once dared imagine what might happen if we never met again.
Frank: (stroking
her arm) The last words
you said to me at the time…so sweet! So wonderfully sweet.
I’ll never forget them.
Ellen: Since then I’ve realised, you know? I’ve realised
that you’re important to me. Essential. You know? You’re
essential in my life! But the easiest thing would obviously be to just
disappear.
Frank: Don’t be crazy! Those three days were wonderful,
really!
Ellen: Don’t you realise that I have no idea how I could
live with you? You can’t just wipe out eleven years of your life. Especially not
you!
Frank: We’ve known each other for two years!
Ellen: Eleven years beats that!
Frank: And we had those three days!
Ellen: Eleven, for crying out loud! Eleven years! (Anna comes back. Ellen turns to the Host) Should
I react to that?
Host: Up to you!
Ellen: Ok then. Will your wife put up a fight?
Frank: I don’t know why you’re bringing that up.
Wouldn’t we be better off trying to make up our minds about what we want to do?
Ellen: Sure! We end this and go home! If we get carried
away and romance blossoms, it will only get harder and harder to make a
decision. It was beautiful, wonderful, you’re the best, in bed and just in
general, but now it’s over! The end!
Frank: Romance would have been spending our time somewhere
in the countryside.
Ellen: The countryside! You always change the subject!
Could it just be possible that you want both of us?
Frank: Probably. Most probably in
fact.
Ellen: But if that isn’t possible now and you have to
decide: why not pick the woman you know? Is it so impossible to have romantic
feelings for someone after eleven years?
Frank: Love, we’re eleven years older! The romance is
pretty worn-out.
Ellen: Time and age don’t mean anything! Nothing at all!
Frank: I beg to differ!
Ellen: Well, I hate these horrible circumstances
anyway!
Frank: My feelings for you are different to those I have
for Anna.
Ellen: Yeah and? What does that mean for us?
Frank: You and I, we’re physically and emotionally more
similar to one another. We’re both just as sensitive. We like the same things
and think the same, we just speak the same
language.
Anna: (sarcastically) Quote, eleven years ago! Your exact words!
Host: (calming her
down) Please, Anna! Be patient.
Ellen: Was it like that with Anna? She seems to remember
it exactly.
Frank: Hmm, I…!
Ellen: So how was it?
Frank: Ok, honestly: I will never forget how she helped
me become a man. That’s for sure. And she really helped me get my promotion.
That’s the truth of the matter. All the paperwork, you know. But it’s hard to
forget the two years when her family made me so miserable.
Ellen: Her family, ha!
Host: Thank you! Let’s pause here. (to the audience) Men, as we well know, do
not always choose the women with whom it is easiest to live. Women are no
different. Why must we fall in love when such difficulties arise from it? Let’s
ask Ellen. You don’t regret accepting my invitation?
Ellen: You’re testing my patience with this
make-believe. I’m worried I’m gonna lose it.
Host: There are many love triangles. And lust is
usually found in just one corner. It is a recurring pattern, in all levels of
society. It affects the young and the old. It is not at all extraordinary, it
has existed all throughout the history of mankind, not literally though, of
course. What should one do in order to win the heart of the desired other? Be oneself or lie? One wavers in indecision. Usually, one does
both, without thinking. We would all like to choose the partner who best
complements us, with whom we are able to live happily, without friction or
opposition. Can you imagine how glorious it would be if all love was
reciprocated, if you had just met Frank and, after falling in love with him, found
out that he loved you too? But sadly that’s not how the world works! No! It
does not! Not always, or rather rarely, do we get the people we desire. And our
inability to fulfil this desire gives us the greatest difficulties of all. Again and again and again. And all over the world! You are
just one in a million, Ellen! What’s so unpleasant about that?
Ellen: I just don’t get why I, of all people, have found
myself in such a stupid situation.
Host: What do you mean?
Ellen: I mean that I hate it when things are difficult. Seriously!
Not being able to do something! There’s something not right in what you just
said. Once I’d set my sights on him, I could get him into bed. But circumstances
have been against me! Otherwise, everything would be practically perfect!
Host: Each one of us has a desire for perfection.
Perfection in what we wear, how we speak, in our jobs and especially in love.
And you had all that under control! No doubt about it! Do you actually have any reason to believe
things are difficult? Here are three people: you, Frank and Anna. There is
nothing unjust about your situation. You are merely weighed down by desires and
problems, which everyone has.
Ellen: I feel, almost physically, that it’s something
unlucky or unpractical, something stupid! Yeah, stupid!
Host: Do you really want him? Is it a question of lust
with love? Or are you by any chance just tired of being alone and simply want a
companion in lust?
Ellen: (angrily)
Lies! It’s all
lies!
Host: Be patient, Ellen! Please, be patient! Have you
lived alone for a long time?
Ellen: I’ve always lived with my parents. My mother’s
still alive, my father’s dead, in case you need to
know that as well.
Host: Do you have any brothers or sisters?
Ellen: No.
Host: What did you father do?
Ellen: He was a lawyer.
Host: How did your parents meet?
Ellen: What’s that got to do with it?
Host: The first encounter is always important. For
instance, how did you meet Frank? Yes, let’s see how you met. Frank, can you
remember?
Frank: The first time I met Ellen?
Host: Do you remember it well?
Frank: Very well!
Host: And Ellen?
Ellen: He hasn’t got a clue about when we first met!
Host: What makes you say that?
Ellen: I’d already been to his seminar a couple of times
and he didn’t even glance at me.
Frank: Rubbish! The second time, the very first thing I
did was see whether you were there!
Host: Ok, that was a silent prelude then. And where did
you first meet properly?
Frank: In the street. She just suddenly spoke to me. It
was a really stupid question. She wanted to know how to get to Leeds Central
Library. She was asking me as someone from Leeds., but
at the time I didn’t know it was her home town.
Host: Please, act it out for us. Tell us your thoughts
as well, so that we know your motives.
Ellen: It’s hard! (looks at the audience)
Host: Don’t worry, they’ve all
been through similar things. So please! How did it happen?
Ellen: He was standing at the bus-stop.
Frank: I was waiting for the Number 95.
Ellen: I plucked up the courage to say: Excuse me, can
you tell me how I get to Leeds Central Library from here?
Frank: (gesturing)
By coming this way with me.
Ellen: Oh, you’re going there too? (to the Host) I
suspected as much!
Frank: The bus isn’t coming anyway,
it’s easy enough to walk there.
Ellen: Yeah? It must be quite far, all the past that
Henry Moore statue.
Frank: Not at all! This is the best way! (starts walking) Come
on! It’s a shortcut!
Ellen: Ok, great! (starts walking too)
Frank: Something only the locals know!
Ellen: Ah, that’s cool!
Frank: Do you like Leeds?
Ellen: The air’s horrid.
Frank: Nothing you can do, it’s a city.
Ellen: And it used to be even worse!
Frank: Do you like it at the University?
Ellen: How come you’re asking that?
Frank: You’re a student, aren’t you?
Ellen: Yeah I am.
Frank: Getting on alright?
Ellen: I’m finding that too much just gets thrown at
us.
Frank: The best thing to do is absorb everything first
and then gradually digest it.
Ellen: Yeah, that’s probably how it should be done.
Frank: By the way, you know, perhaps I’m being too
bold here, but I like listening to you talk.
Ellen: Do you?
Frank: I could walk and listen to you like this for
hours!
Ellen: Ah, am I right, that building there?
Frank: Come on, I’ll show you...
Host: Thank you! And since then have you often been
to Leeds Central Library together?
Frank: I wouldn’t say often.
Ellen: Only when it came about, just because.
Host: I see. And what happened: did you tell her you
were married?
Frank: Yeah, it was at the bus-stop again, I think.
Ellen: Yeah, the weather was miserable. I had a
feeling he was going to take advantage of the situation.
Host: Please show us.
Frank: Well, umm, she was standing there, waiting
under the shelter. And, as I came up, I saw that she was looking, as if she was
waiting for me.
Host: (to Ellen)
Is that right?
Ellen: He wanted to come past, but I stepped forward
so that he couldn’t.
Frank: And I started going: blah blah blah, miserable
weather, or something like that.
Ellen: Yeah, you started talking about your winter
coat.
Frank: That’s it! I said: I almost put my winter coat
on.
Ellen: (laughs) I’ve
got mine on.
Frank: (stepping
from side to side, clearly hurried) Clever girl, eh!
Ellen: The bus should be here soon.
Frank: Sorry, I can’t get it today. I have to hurry to
get home. My...my wife’s expecting me.
Ellen: All the nice guys are married. That’s what they
say.
Frank: I’m nice?
Ellen: What does your wife do?
Frank: She’s a teacher but she doesn’t work anymore.
Her family don’t want her to work, you know. We live
with her family... because it’s somehwere to live.
Ellen: I’m single.
Frank: Oh great! Excuse me, I have to go now.
Ellen: Of course. Of course, goodbye.
Frank: Goodbye. (Leaves)
Host: (to
Ellen) What did you think when he told you that so
casually like that?
Ellen: I shouldn’t get too attracted to him.
Host: Which is something you didn’t keep to?
Ellen: In the beginning I did. But then, one day, out
of the blue, I told Frank that he should visit me sometime and bring his wife
along.
Host: So you cunningly sezied the opportunity in the
situation?
Ellen: Is that how you’d describe it?
Host: One might interpret it in such a way.
Ellen: I wanted him to come to mine. Perhaps it was a
crazy idea but with his wife there, it would be a completely harmless visit.
Host: And did this visit happen?
Ellen: Yes.
Host: (to
Frank) Was it not quite odd? Taking your wife to a
student’s home?
Frank: Of course it was! But when I think back on it
now, I was really curious to see how this woman lived.
Ellen: And be close to me!
Frank: Yes, that too! If my wife went with me, it was
as harmless as it could be, for my wife as well.
Host: That’s logical. This visit is interesting.
Anna, please join in, it’s important for you too. Come on!
Anna: If you want. (comes onto the stage)
Host: Please, cast your mind back. How did it all
happen? Let’s imagine that this is Ellen’s flat. No need for introductions. (Ellen, Anna and Frank get into position) So,
everyone ready? Then off you go!
Ellen: Pleased to meet you. Frank, er, your husband
has told me a lot about you.
Anna: He’s talked a lot about you too. You’ve
furnished it lovely. It must be nice to have a flat like this.
Ellen: Please, sit down!
Frank: Thank you. Yes, you do have refined taste.
Anna: Frank, do you think we’ll ever have a flat like
this?
Frank: Why not?
Ellen: Just a little snack. Please help yourself!
Frank: Ah, you’re a good cook, eh?
Anna: Mmm, it’s amazing.
Frank: Ah, and there, the complete works of Thomas
Hardy. Exclusively from HarperCollins, if I’m not mistaken. Can’t find that
anywhere these days!
Ellen: (to Anna)
Would you like a cigarette?
Anna: Yes, thank you. Do you see Frank often at
University?
Ellen: Yeah, I suppose. I attend his seminar once a
week.
Frank: You really do have a mini library here!
Ellen: You’re exaggerating. Some of the books belong
to a friend. Unfortunately, I can’t buy everything I want.
Frank: Ah, what’s this I see: Lady Chatterley! (picks the book up)
Ellen: Of all the books you could have picked up...
Anna: The sex story?
Frank: She’s not that bad!
Anna: I think we should go now.
Ellen: Oh please don’t, not yet. (takes the book from Frank) You’re so
nosy! Coming here and rummaging around in my books.
Frank: Sorry!
Anna: It was nice of you to invite us. I wasn’t sure
but then I just wanted to see for myself this student that Frank is nurturing
so selflessly.
Frank: Oh, am I?
Anna: Or am I exaggerating?
Ellen: I don’t know. Your husband is very fair. He
nurtures everyone actually.
Frank: Ok, that’s enough on the subject. It was nice
to have come but now we really must leave. Goodbye, see you tomorrow! (leaves the stage)
Anna: Goodbye, good luck with your studies. (leaves the stage)
(Ellen also wants to leave)
Host: Ellen, hang on a moment, please! Tell us, was
the farewell really so abrupt?
Ellen: No! It went a bit differently to that.
Host: And what was your impression of Anna? At the time?
Ellen: Hmm, how shall I put it...
She seemed quite artificial. I don’t particularly like the woman and I have a
feeling she’s not that fond of me either.
Anna: Correct!
Host: (raises
his hand to calm them down then turns to Ellen) How long were you together
that evening?
Ellen: Quite a while I think. It was strange. It
always seemed as if there was a row waiting to happen and yet the two of them
just stayed there like they couldn’t like leave.
Host: Did Anna talk about herself?
Ellen: More than I did about myself anyway.
Host: And how did you find Frank?
Ellen: It was quite unsettling for me. He seemed to
show his wife more affection than I had hoped.
Host: And vice versa?
Ellen: She seemed quite independent of him.
Anna: Just a minute, young lady!
Host: Please, Anna! (to Ellen) So you thought that the two of
them were closer than you’d have liked?
Ellen: I don’t think that’s what I thought. I just
didn’t want to think about it at all.
Host: I see. What was your attitude towards Frank
after this visit?
Ellen: I had one thing confirmed: his private life was
off limits.
Host: Did you say that to Frank?
Ellen: Of course not.
Host: So you had a clear feeling that you were better
off keeping your distance?
Ellen: Yes.
Host: Did Anna encourage that at all? Did you, for
example, get the impression that evening that Anna said something on the side
that was actually meant for you personally?
Ellen: I don’t think so. She talked more to fill time
and to hide her feelings.
Anna: Nonsense!
Host: Please, patience, Mrs Manz.
Anna: Maybe I should just listen quietly?
Host: Wouldn‘t you rather leave us alone for a
moment?
Anna: Yes, I would! (gets up)
Host: My assistent will get you something to drink
outside. (Anna leaves) Did Anna
flatter you and say nice things?
Ellen: Yes.
Host: Did you think her sincere?
Ellen: No.
Host: (to
Frank) Do you think she was suspicious and wanted to find something out?
Frank: No idea. But I must have told her a lot about
Ellen, without meaning to, more than I should have.
Host: Did Anna suspect you had feelings for Ellen?
Frank: I don’t think so but I’m not sure. She was
probably suspicious the whole time about something or other but I didn’t notice
at all.
Host: (to the
audience) This is often the case, secret lovers
have no real control over themselves anymore. They behave conspicuously and
unsually, without noticing. (to Frank) Were you living with Anna’s family at that
time?
Frank: Yes.
Host: And you developped a certain dislike of that
family?
Frank: There was already a sort of reservation. And
that’s when it escalated.
Host: You were afraid of getting found out.
Frank: I can’t remember.
Host: Did you pass on your certain aversion to her
family onto your wife?
Frank: Probably.
Host: But by living with Anna’s family, you were able
to write your dissertation?
Frank: It was a catch-22.
Host: In what way?
Frank: I would have had to stay in halls. In Anna’s
parents’ house, I had peace and quiet. And the main thing was that I didn’t
have to worry about anything, only my work. Anna had my back. She also wrote
out every page, sometime twice or three times, when it had to be reworked.
Host: I see. Tell us, were you ever involved in
another affair, before you met Ellen?
Frank: No. That’s not what I’m like.
Host: How long had you been living with Anna’s family
when you met Ellen?
Frank: About seven, eight months.
Host: And how much longer did you stay there for?
Frank: A good year.
Host: And in this time, you grew more and more
interested in Ellen.
Frank: Yes.
Host: So the relationship didn’t develop quickly. You
took over a year. Is that not quite a long time for two grown adults?
(Ellen and Frank laugh in agreement)
Ellen: Thank you.
Host: Surprisingly long, in fact. Frank, how long did
it take you to become acquainted with Anna?
Frank: With Anna? Hmm, a couple of
weeks or so.
Host: So everything just flowed then, compared to this.
What caused your particularly slow progression towards your goal? Did you even
have one?
Frank: Goal…that’s not the right word. I didn’t have a
goal. Something just sprang up inside me. I had no hand in it. That’s why I was
so uncertain. With Anna, I wanted her. With Ellen…
Host: Yes?
Frank: Ok. Ultimately, I wanted her too.
Host: Can you explain why you wasted so much time?
Frank: Hey, listen! As a married man, you’re bound to be
hesitant, if you still have some integrity. Right?
Host: So the fact that you’re married was what held you
back?
Frank: Well, yes, definitely!
Host: You never had the desire to get closer to her and
tell her that you loved her?
Frank: But of course!
Ellen: I could sense it!
Host: (turning to
her) But you held back as well?
Ellen: Sort of.
Host: A barrier went up when you found out that he was
married. How long after your first encounter did he tell you?
Ellen: About six weeks.
Host: And by this time, you were already sure of your
feelings for Frank?
Ellen: I guess so. Otherwise I’d hardly have had the
courage to invite them round. You know, sometimes people do things even they don’t understand.
Host: Right, we’ve already spoken about that. So then
there was this visit. Did you do anything afterwards to stop him seeing you or
to make it more difficult?
Ellen: I avoided him for a while. I’m not proud of that
now.
Host: And you, Frank?
Frank: At first, I suppressed my feelings, really
suppressed them. And yet I was always trying to get close to her.
Host: Were you afraid of losing her?
Frank: I wouldn’t have told Ellen I loved her if that
situation hadn’t come about.
Host: So the situation arose?
Frank: Yes, somehow.
Host: Reconstruct this situation. Please!
Frank: Yeah, hmm... It was at University, after a
lecture. We just happened to meet. Is that right?
Ellen: Yeah.
Frank: Somehow you’d been determined for us to meet.
Anyway, you suddenly stopped mid-step. I was directly behind you, I couldn’t
dodge you.
Ellen: Yeah.
Frank: All of a sudden, I heard myself saying something
like: Ellen, do you have a minute?
Ellen: Yes, that’s what he said. And I didn’t know
whether I should.
Frank: And I thought: She has to come this time. What a
day! I said. Utter madness.
Ellen: It was like a dream. I didn’t want to talk
intimately with him, that I was sure
of.
Host: But you stopped mid-step?
Ellen: Yeah, ridiculous!
Host: Please, act it out!
Frank: Shall we sit down?
Host: Sit down?
Frank: Yeah, the walking bit, we’re not gonna be able to
do that now. We’re sitting on a bench.
Host: Go ahead!
(Ellen and Frank sit down)
Frank: Yes, now how did it happen again? God, I’m just
as flustered again now.
Ellen: I think I said: Actually, I don’t have any time.
Frank: Yes, yes! And I went: Do you know, I’ve honestly
met all kinds of women, but with you, I don’t know where I stand.
Ellen: You haven’t had much of a chance to get to know
me as a woman.
Frank: Actually, I haven’t got to know much about you.
Ellen: (to
the Host) That’s how I wanted
it to be.
Host: Good, good, carry on.
Frank: Do you know, that’s why now, it’s, I’ve got a job in London.
Ellen: London?
Frank: It’ll give me the opportunity to find out whether I’ve got what it
takes to be a successful academic. But I don’t like the thought that then I’d
have to leave.
Ellen: So just stay.
Frank: Would you miss me?
Ellen: Maybe.
Frank: I’ll miss you. I will.
Ellen: Yeah?
Frank: I’m been dreaming about you for weeks.
Ellen: I’ve dreamt about you too. Then I guessed why…and
tried to forget.
Frank: Where’s this going?
Ellen: Where can it go?
Frank: We’ve never once talked about us, properly. I
have to leave in three weeks!
Ellen: Then I’ll just have to get over it somehow.
Frank: I could stay here, but I’m still married. What would come of it?
Ellen: Nothing good, I imagine.
Frank: I don’t know what I can do about leaving you
behind like this. I have loved you for much longer than I’ve liked to
admit.
Ellen: Well, what can we do?
Frank: I’m afraid there’s nothing we can do. The best
thing will probably be to say goodbye and forget it. Throw ourselves into work
and forget it all. Shit!
Ellen: Yeah, shit!
Frank: Should we not at least try to be together as much
as possible during these last three weeks?
Ellen: We just have to accept it.
Frank: If only it had only just begun! But now! My feelings haven’t faded
one bit!
Ellen: Really?
Frank: I cannot and will not let you go like this!
Ellen: Just sleep with me at least.
Frank: Would you?
Ellen: Let’s go.
Frank: Now?
Ellen: Or never!
Frank: Let’s meet on Thursday, in the library, about half
seven.
Ellen: (getting
up) Maybe.
Host: Thank you very much. Please, keep going
straightaway. You’re doing well. Show us this Thursday! Did Ellen come?
Frank: She came much later than I had hoped. I was there
by 7 o’clock and pretended to do some work. But I couldn’t get rid of the
thought that she would make her ‘now or never’ remark a reality and not come.
What should I do if she didn’t come? I played the scene from Tuesday over and
over again in my head and became more and more certain that she wouldn’t come.
I felt like an idiot for not seizing the opportunity. I keep imagining what it
would be like to hold her naked in my arms, just once in my lifetime. Sheer
madness! I couldn’t work. Eventually she came, sat elsewhere, away from me. We
sat at different tables and pretended to be really busy. That went on until
about quarter to eight. Then finally, I took my life in my hands, which, by the
way, were shaking, and
went over to her, acting like it was a coincidence.
Host: And you Ellen?
Ellen: I thought: I’m a fool for coming here. Just
sleeping with a man when you know it’s not going to turn into anything, well,
it’s not really that exciting then. But it all turned out so differently! I
wished I’d never started this relationship. Just a waste of time, that’s what I
thought. And yet...
Host: Thank you. Frank, anything else you remember?
Frank: Hmm, I was only thinking one thing: How am I ever
going to get her out of here? And I suddenly wondered how many people there
must have already recognised us. I felt like they were all just waiting for us
to eventually leave together. Something we had never done before. One of us
always went first and the other waited for a bit. Then I started working myself
up. She wasn’t leaving and letting me follow. Suddenly I was scared of going
first because maybe then she wouldn’t follow. And then it hit me: This is
crazy, you’ve been married for eleven years and now you’re acting like a
schoolboy!
Host: Thank you. (to Ellen) Anything else?
Ellen: Hmm, all the thoughts were jumbled in my head! I
felt quite dizzy. Should I go over to his table? I could barely control my
feelings. Everything was a blur! Everything!
Frank: By the way, I was thinking about Anna too. What
would she say if she knew? I knew that I mustn’t make a drama out of our
marriage. We were, in a way, happy, albeit not in recent years. I’ve known
Ellen for two years now. A year and a half. And now
it’s the end for us. Funny. You marry someone, it’s so
great, then, all of a sudden, someone else comes
along. I didn’t think I could love someone like that.
Host: Good, let’s act that out now! (to Ellen)
You’re sitting there at your desk in the library (Ellen sits down), and Frank has just summoned up the courage to
approach you.
Frank: (going up to Ellen) Hello!
Ellen:
Hello!
Frank:
Here you are.
Ellen:
Here I am.
Frank:
Finished your work?
Ellen:
Not really.
Frank:
Shall we go?
Ellen:
I just have to pack my things away.
Frank:
I’ll help you.
Ellen: It’s
ok! (she gets up
and leaves)
Frank: (following her) You
don’t really think I’d let you go now do you?
Ellen:
No?
Frank:
Wait a minute! Please! (they pause) Do you know, (looks at the clock) you got here nearly an hour late?
Ellen: It
was a difficult decision. Or was it not for you?
Frank:
I only have an hour left!
Ellen:
Let’s have a drink.
Frank:
Somewhere round here?
Ellen:
I think all pubs are dreadful.
Frank:
We’ll just go in the first good one we see.
Ellen:
Ah, here’s one actually.
Frank:
What a dive.
Ellen:
A serious dive.
Frank:
We can go in the room behind the bar.
Ellen:
See, you know your way around.
Frank:
From a long time ago. So, what would you like to drink?
Ellen:
Vodka.
Frank:
Vodka? Same here.
Ellen:
I prefer it with soda.
Frank:
I’ll have it neat.
Ellen:
Brr!!
Frank:
What? Shoots straight through you.
Ellen:
Such a strange place. All that racket at the bar.
Frank:
What shall we do now?
Ellen:
I don’t know.
Frank:
Such a crazy situation. Let’s go somewhere we can talk.
Ellen:
Anything’s better than this dive.
Frank:
Tell me about it! (they
leave) All I’ve thought about since Thursday is us.
Ellen:
Me too. I thought about what you’d probably say to me and me to you. (they stop)
Frank:
It took us nearly two years to confess our love for each other. Now I’m
leaving, in three weeks... (takes her in his arms) out of your life. I love you! I
don’t know how long I’ve loved you for or when it started. It was just there. It’s madness, but I love you!
(Ellen kisses him)
Frank: I
don’t want to end this now.
Ellen:
What shall we do?
Frank: I
wish I knew.
Ellen:
Me too.
Frank:
See you tomorrow, I’m too late now!
(she kisses him)
Frank: (looking at the clock) See you tomorrow then.
Ellen: Great.
Frank: Where?
Ellen:
At mine.
Host:
Thank you very much. That was insightful. Did you still see each other often
after that?
Frank:
As often as we could.
Host:
During that time, did you have any morbid thoughts?
Frank:
What do you mean?
Host:
That life had no meaning if you couldn’t be together.
Frank:
Yes, I did. On several occasions, I wished my wife was dead and often that I
was too.
Host:
And Ellen?
Ellen:
No, I didn’t. I always thought I’d cope, I’d survive.
Host:
Such a thought never even occurred to you?
Ellen:
I never thought of doing anything but accepting things as they were, although it
did seem quite hopeless.
Host:
You really thought there would be some kind of solution?
Ellen:
No, I thought there was no hope. He couldn’t leave his wife.
Host:
You had a feeling that he would leave you?
Ellen:
Yes.
Host:
Did you ever speak to Frank about your feelings?
Ellen:
I just wanted my feelings gone.
Host:
What do you mean?
Ellen:
I wanted to not want anymore.
Host:
You wanted to stop longing for a man?
Ellen:
I thought it would be possible for me to get on with my life and only worry
about the little things. When Frank went, I thought my world would fall apart.
Host:
But he didn’t leave you.
Ellen:
That confused me. There was a constant attraction between us, even beyond
physical presence.
Host:
What is it that draws people to each other when they are in love?
Ellen:
Curiosity.
Frank:
In love, there’s nothing worse than being boring.
Ellen:
I could never fall in love with someone boring. I think that’s why I fell in
love with you.
Host:
You never felt any physical attraction?
(Ellen hesitates)
Anna: (in the background) I did!
Host: Ah, Anna, nice
of you to come back. Please, come closer. Before the break, I would like you to
act out another scene with your husband. Ellen, thank you very much, you can
have a seat again in the meantime. Yes, Anna, so, your interjection contradicts
what Frank told us before. But that happens in marriage. One person has
completely different notions of sensuality in a marital relationship to the
other. Let’s try to look at the problem more closely. Your husband here
explained to us that he became impatient with your lack of independence. Is
that something he often accused you of?
Frank: Objection!
Host: Sorry, did I
misquote you?
Frank: That’s just what
people say, you’re putting words in my mouth!
Host: If I remember
correctly, your wife didn’t work originally. Did that come about on your
request or did she not want to work?
Frank: She worked for
me.
Host: In what way?
Frank: She typed up my
manuscripts.
Host: Right, you said
that already. And she never expressed a desire to get a regular job?
Frank: You’re asking
me?
Host: The question was
aimed more at the both of you. Please enact the scene in which your wife
informed you that she was thinking of going to work in the future. Anna, can
you remember roughly how that went?
Anna: I was sitting at
the computer, typing for him. It was very late by then and I was tired.
Frank: She didn’t
understand that the article had to be finished by the deadline.
Host: Please, act it
out! (Anna und Frank take a seat)
Anna: How many more
pages?
Frank: (counting) Two,
four, six...
Anna: I need a drink
first.
Frank: It’s already
late.
Anna: Exactly, I’ll
fall asleep otherwise. You know, this division of labour in our marriage, it’s
not going to work in the long-run.
Frank: What’s that
supposed to mean?
Anna: Didn’t you say
yourself that I’m too dependent? I thought you wanted me to go to work, earn
some money.
Frank: Nonsense! You
know full well that’s not what I meant. I want to come home to a level-headed
wife, not one that’s drained and worn out from work.
Anna: Do you really
mean that?
Frank: Just look
around, at University, in all institutions: the men who can get ahead in
academia all have a woman looking after them at home. Do you really think I’d
ever be able to become a professor if I started doing the washing up and
running the house as well?
Anna: You forgot the
washing, vacuuming, shopping, window cleaning and cooking.
Frank: Funny.
Anna: As soon as we
get to London, I’m going to work as a teacher.
Frank: Oh no you won’t.
Anna: Oh yes I will.
Frank: Anna, I’ve
always thought you were alright like this?
Anna: Something’s not
right between us.
Frank: Well what is it
then?
Anna: I’m not
independent. You noticed it and, as a matter of fact, you’re right. Please, let
me say this now: I’m basically dependent on you. If you ever left
me...
Frank: Anna!
Anna: ...I’d have to
start from scratch and I wouldn’t have a clue what to do in life. I’d have to
work eventually, you know, otherwise I’d shrivel up.
Frank: I don’t think that’d
go well. Anyway, I need order at home, my emotional equilibrium, mental and
physical balance, you know? I have to be able to unwind with you, (moves closer to her) and so you can’t
be exhausted. It’s in your best interests too...
Anna: (escaping him) The
manuscript!
Frank: There’s plenty
of time! (undoes
her dress)
Anna: There’s six sides left!
Frank: They’ll still be
there after!
Host: Thank you, thank
you! If I understand correctly, some quite common arguments were put forward.
Were they convincing?
Anna: They wore thin.
Since we’ve been in London, I’ve been working as a teacher. I’m enjoying it.
Host: And you’ve done
nothing to stop her?
Frank: No.
Host: You were quietly
hoping that she would break up with you.
Frank: That’s not what
I was hoping. I love my wife.
(Ellen jumps up)
Host: (to Ellen) He loves her too! (to the audience) That’s
his problem. It seems to me that the thing that would please him most would be
if we here were to come to the opinion here today that it was completely normal
for a man to live with two women. All three of them in love! Not an entirely
new concept, as you well know. It was Goethe’s dream before now. It seems to me
that declaring such a love triangle to the whole world is still better than
lust without love. If you know what I mean. Here (reaches inside his jacket), I cut this
out. Listen to what a young chef told a newspaper recently. His exact words
were: “Why eat chips every day, when you can have tortellini? I sleep around
just for the fun of it. You can meet nice girls every night in clubs. Who’d
turn that down? It isn’t a betrayal in love, sex has
nothing to do with it. My girlfriend can do what she wants too.” End of
quotation. This young man thinks himself lucky getting to shag around. Or take
this student – he says: “Personally, I’ve got four girls on the go. But that’s
normal. I meet a lot of girls at parties. Should I just brush them off? They
want something from me as well you know. And that’s how it happens. A bit of
flirting, meet up a few times… it’s all part of life.” End of quotation.
Conclusion: sex without love is the chosen ideal. So,
essentially, nothing other than degeneration into the animal world.
Let’s be clear that our three subjects are far from that. They’re making it
hard for themselves. And that, in turn, makes it hard for us to find a workable
solution. The problem is: lust with love must be mastered. That it is to say:
we should ask ourselves whether there isn’t something stronger than love. But
I’m getting ahead of myself. I think our three subjects have earned themselves a
break. Let’s end the first session. But please don’t run off, I’m afraid I’ll be needing you to take part in an audience vote.
(Break)